My Favorite Skill to Teach: Immediacy and the Here and Now. Immediacy in Counseling is so Cool.
Oct 26
6 min read

By Dr. John O'Malley, PhD, LPC · Couples Therapist and Clinical Supervisor · Golden, Colorado
Most of my blogs are about couples counseling. Today I'm taking a little break and heading over to the training side of my work, since I'm a Clinical Professor at the University of Denver and I also provide clinical supervision for counselors working toward licensure.
This morning I taught one of my favorite skills in our Basic Counseling Techniques course: immediacy, or working in the here and now. And I'll be honest with you, just as I was with my students. I love teaching this skill, and often it goes in one ear and out the other. Sometimes, including my own.
What immediacy in counseling is
Immediacy is talking about what is happening between you and the person in front of you, right here, right now. My own definition is simple: having the courage to talk about what is happening between the therapist and the client without creating unnecessary defensiveness.
If you go into the literature, you'll see folks talk about it like this:
Yalom (2002) describes the here and now as the immediate events that happen in a counseling session, what is happening "here (in this office, in this relationship, in the in-betweenness, the space between me and you) now" (p. 46).
Kiesler (1988, 1996) called immediacy metacommunication.
Because most clients talk in the past tense, Ivey (1994) described immediacy as being "in the moment" with the client.
Sullivan (1953), a neo-Freudian, believed personality theory and therapy should emphasize the dynamic between people.
And my favorite, Yalom (2002) called the here and now "the major source of therapeutic power, the dirt of therapy, the therapist's best friend" (p. 46).
I really like how Dr. Clara Hill and her colleagues unpack it in their book Helping Skills. They break immediacy into four types, and naming them is what finally made it click for many of my students. Below are the four, with a couple's example for each, since that is the room I sit in most days.
1. Questions and probes about the relationship
This is the gentlest door. You invite the client, or in my world the couple, to say what they might be holding back, especially negative reactions. Clients often won't share those unless we ask.
In couples work it might sound like:
"I wonder what reactions the two of you are having right now, here with me?"
Or:
"What is it like to talk about this in front of me today?"
2. The helper's disclosure about reactions to the client
Here I share my own reaction, briefly, as honest feedback about the impact someone is having on another person. Then I hand it right back.
"As I hear you talk, I know your partner has said they feel disconnected from you. I notice I'm feeling a little disconnected from you too right now. I wonder how you're feeling in here today?"
Or:
"I know there is hurt underneath this. And I notice I'm having a hard time staying with that hurt, because I feel like I'm being kept at arm's length. What comes up as you hear me say that?"
3. Making the covert overt
This brings hidden reactions into the open so they can be talked about. I describe what I just saw, then I get curious.
"When we just went over your negative cycle, I could tell that was hard on you. What's going on for you right now?"
Or:
"I'm noticing you pulled back in your chair just now. I wonder what's happening inside?"
4. Drawing parallels with outside relationships
This one is my favorite, because it helps folks see their pattern happening live, right in the room.
"You've shared that you shut down when you feel criticized. Just now, when your partner said something that may have landed as criticism, I saw you shut down and pull away. I wonder if this is what happens at home when I'm not in the room?"
One of my favorite examples
One of my favorite examples comes from Irvin Yalom's The Gift of Therapy. He shares saying this to a client:
"I often feel caught in a dilemma: on the one hand I wish to be more natural with you and yet, on the other hand, because I feel that you're easily wounded and that you give my comments inordinate power, I feel I must consider my wording very, very carefully."
I love this one. It is the helper's disclosure about reactions to the client, offered with so much care. He isn't blaming. He is naming what it is like to be with this person, right now. And it opens a door for the client to wonder whether other people in their life feel the same way, which is where it can move into drawing parallels with outside relationships.
Why we do this
One of my students asked a great question today: why do we even do this? Because our whole lives are lived in relationship. How we show up with the people we love is going to show up with our counselor, psychologist, therapist, or whatever professional identity is in the room. Being able to name that, and use it to help the client, matters.
The research backs this up. The here and now is one of the more effective interventions for helping clients with lasting change (Cavdar & Fisek, 2018; Henderson & Poppen, 1995; Kivlighan, 2014; Mayotte-Blum et al., 2012; Sackett, Lawson, & Burge, 2012; Turock, 1980). Hill and colleagues (2013) found that immediacy isn't used often and needs to be used well, but when it is, it can move therapy forward and help clients gain insight.
Here is why it works:
The session is a microcosm of how clients relate to others in the world (Sullivan, 1953). It gives us a window into how others might experience the client outside of our office.
We feel the pattern ourselves. Because I personally experience the impact of a client's pattern (that pull to act a certain way around them), I can help them become aware of it and practice something new, right there with me.
It makes the covert direct. What is hinted at or acted out can finally be talked about.
It repairs ruptures. When something goes wrong between us and we repair it together, that repair becomes practice for repairing relationships outside of counseling.
That is why I tell my students: your private emotional reactions are clinical information. And in couples work, the microcosm is right there in front of me. Two people bring their pattern into my office, and it plays out live.
I also told my students that I think we still have a little bit of time before AI completely replaces us. I'm sure it will get closer. But being able to name what is happening right here, right now, in the room, the energy, the relationship, is one of the things that makes therapy so unique and special. It's also why I love couples counseling. It's the place where I get to do this the most.
Nice versus kind
We talked about the difference between being nice and being kind. I think a lot of us are scared to use immediacy because we care about people. We don't want to upset anyone. But if we can see that a pattern is getting in the way, why wouldn't we find a way to bring it up and really help? Can we tap into a place of love, kindness, and care, and say the hard thing from there? That is the difference. It's not just being nice, it's being kind.
My favorite comment of the day came from a student who said, "I wish my therapist did something like this." I'll take that one home with me.
I had a lot of fun with this group today. They showed a ton of self-awareness. They named that this is hard, admitted they found themselves questioning it a little, and then started to see the value. That is exactly how learning this skill goes, for all of us.
How I teach it now (a little confession)
Most folks who know me know I didn't have the best K through 12 experience. I struggled. But something I learned in middle school still comes with me today: the Sentence Writing Strategy from the University of Kansas. It taught us to label what we were doing. To this day I know that D, comma, I means a dependent clause, then a comma, then an independent clause.
So I borrowed that idea. I built worksheets that give each type of immediacy its own simple formula, with a model, then less and less support, until you are writing it on your own. All the credit for the four types goes to Dr. Hill. I just tried to make them stick.
The handouts are below. If you are a therapist or a counselor educator, please use them.
Looking for supervision?
If you are a pre-licensed counselor (LPCC) in Colorado working toward your LPC, or you know someone who is, I'd be happy to help. My supervision group meets online on Wednesdays at noon, and you can drop in. I also offer individual supervision, in person or online. You can read more and fill out the interest form on my supervision page, and we'll start with a free 20-minute consultation.
And if you and your partner are feeling stuck in the same pattern, this is the work I do every day. You can learn how I work on my EFT couples therapy page, or book a free consultation.