The Blame Game, Hide and Seek, or Roommates? Which Pattern Are You Stuck In (and Which Horsemen Ride Along)
Oct 31
12 min read

By Dr. John O'Malley, PhD, LPC · Couples Therapist and Clinical Supervisor · Golden, Colorado
Written for couples. Counselors in training, there's a section for you near the end.
The short answer. Sue Johnson found what pattern you are stuck in fall into three demon dialogues. I call them the Blame Game, Hide and Seek, and Roommates. John Gottman found four behaviors that predict relationships falling apart: criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling. Put the two together and you get a map. The dance tells you what pattern you're in. The horsemen tell you which moves keep it going. There's a free self-assessment below so each of you can find both.
Devon and Jules have been together twelve years. They've had three different marriages in that time, and all three were with each other.
The first one was loud. Every disagreement turned into a trial. Who forgot to call the plumber. Who said what at Thanksgiving. Both of them were sharp, both were sure they were right, and both left the room keeping score.
The second one was a chase. Jules would bring something up. Devon would say, "Can we not do this tonight?" Jules would follow Devon into the kitchen. Devon would go to the garage. Jules would stand in the garage doorway. Round and round, for about five years.
The third one is the one they're in now. It's quiet. They're very good at logistics. The kids get to practice, the bills get paid, the calendar is color-coded. They haven't had a real fight in a year. They also haven't had a real conversation.
"We're not fighting anymore," Jules told me. "Isn't that supposed to be good?"
Devon and Jules are invented. I made up the names and every detail. The three stages are real, and I see couples in each one.
The three demon dialogues, in plain words, to help answer: What Pattern Are You Stuck In
Sue Johnson, who developed Emotionally Focused Therapy, spends the first conversation in Hold Me Tight on what she calls the demon dialogues. Her names for them are Find the Bad Guy, the Protest Polka, and Freeze and Flee. (Love me some Sue Johnson.)
Her names are memorable. In my office, I've found couples connect faster with plainer ones. So here's what I call them.
1. The Blame Game (Johnson's Find the Bad Guy). Both of you are attacking. Every fight becomes a courtroom, and someone has to be found guilty. You might win the argument. The relationship loses it.
2. Hide and Seek (Johnson's Protest Polka). One of you seeks. "Talk to me. Why won't you deal with this?" The other one hides. "I'm not doing this right now." The more one seeks, the more the other hides. The more one hides, the harder the other seeks. Johnson considers this the most common of the three, and it's the one I see most.
3. Roommates (Johnson's Freeze and Flee). Nobody is seeking anymore. Both of you have pulled back to protect yourselves. The house runs. The hearts don't. Johnson describes this as what often happens after a long run of the polka, when the seeking partner finally gives up.
That's exactly what happened to Devon and Jules.
All three are versions of the squirrel in the house, my name for the negative cycle. The squirrel just behaves differently depending on which room it's in.
The Four Horsemen: Quickly to help answer what Pattern Are You Stuck In
John Gottman studied couples for decades and found four behaviors that predict a relationship breaking down. He calls them the Four Horsemen:
Criticism. Going after who your partner is instead of what happened. "You're so selfish," instead of "I was hurt you didn't call."
Contempt. Acting from above your partner. Eye rolls, sarcasm, mockery, that little smirk. Gottman's research found contempt to be the single strongest predictor of divorce.
Defensiveness. Protecting yourself by denying, explaining, or counter-attacking. "Well, you do it too."
Stonewalling. Shutting down. Going quiet, looking away, leaving.
Here's how I put the two models together for couples. Gottman shows you what is damaging the relationship. Johnson shows you why you both keep doing it.
Because nobody wakes up wanting to be contemptuous. From an EFT lens, every horseman is a protest or a protection:
Criticism is usually protest. It's a seeker's way of saying "I can't reach you," turned up too loud.
Contempt is protest that has hardened. When the "I need you" goes unanswered long enough, the hurt can curdle into judgment.
Defensiveness is protection. It guards against the feeling that you've failed, again.
Stonewalling is protection too. It's what a body does when it's flooded and can't take in one more thing.
How the horsemen ride in each dance
Each dance has its own favorite horsemen.
The Blame Game: everybody brought a horse
In the Blame Game, both partners use criticism and defensiveness, and contempt tends to show up as the fights get older. One attacks, the other defends by attacking back, and now there are two prosecutors and no jury.
What it sounds like: "You always do this." "Oh, I always do this? Let's talk about last weekend." An eye roll. A long sigh. A list.
What's underneath: two people who each feel unseen, both trying to get the other to finally admit it.
Hide and Seek: different partners, different horsemen
Hide and Seek is the clearest place to see that the horsemen depend on your role.
The seeker usually leads with criticism. "Why is everything more important than us?" If that doesn't get a response, contempt can creep in. "Forget it. I don't know why I bother."
The hider usually leads with defensiveness. "That's not fair. I work all week for this family." If the pressure keeps coming, stonewalling follows. Silence. The phone. The garage.
What's underneath: the seeker fears being alone in the relationship. The hider is scared of never getting it right. Either partner, of any gender, can be the seeker or the hider, and some couples switch depending on the topic. (I wrote a whole post with five mantras for breaking this one, under its original name, the protest polka.)
Roommates: the quiet horsemen
Roommates looks peaceful, which is why it fools people. The main horseman here is stonewalling, from both partners, so constant it stops feeling like a choice. The second is a quiet kind of contempt. Nobody's rolling their eyes. There's just a cool, flat indifference, a sense that it isn't worth trying anymore.
What it sounds like: very little. "Did you pay the water bill?" "Yep."
What's underneath: two people who both stopped reaching because reaching kept hurting. This is the pattern that worries me most, because there's no fight to tell you something's wrong.
Dance | Main horsemen | The fear underneath |
The Blame Game | Criticism and defensiveness from both, contempt as it wears on | "You don't see me, and I have to prove it." |
Hide and Seek | Seeker: criticism, then contempt. Hider: defensiveness, then stonewalling | Seeker: "I'm alone in this." Hider: "I can never get it right." |
Roommates | Stonewalling from both, quiet contempt | "Reaching isn't safe anymore." |
The self-assessment: find your horsemen and your dance
This has two parts. Part A shows which horsemen you bring most often. Part B shows which dance the two of you fall into.
A few ground rules before you start:
Each of you takes it on your own. Don't peek. Compare afterward.
Answer about yourself, not your partner. Part A is only about your own moves. That's the whole point.
Think about the last month. Not your best week. Not your worst one.
Be honest. Nobody gets graded. Everybody has a horse or two. Me included.
One honest note: I built this reflection tool from Johnson's and Gottman's work. It's clinically informed. It isn't a validated psychological test, and it can't diagnose anything. Think of it as a conversation starter.
Use this scale for every item: 0 = Never · 1 = Sometimes · 2 = Often · 3 = Almost always
Part A: Which horsemen do I bring?
When my partner and I disagree, I...
Criticism
Start with "you always" or "you never."
Talk about what's wrong with my partner instead of what I need.
Bring up old problems while we're trying to solve a new one.
Feel like I have to say it louder or stronger before it'll land.
Contempt
5. Roll my eyes, smirk, or use sarcasm.
6. Correct my partner in a tone that says I know better.
7. Mock or imitate my partner, even as a "joke."
8. Privately think my partner is the bigger problem in this relationship.
Defensiveness
9. Explain why it wasn't my fault before owning any part of it.
10. Answer a complaint with a complaint of my own.
11. Feel like the innocent one, or the only one really trying.
12. Hear a request ("I wish you would...") as an attack.
Stonewalling
13. Go quiet, look away, or reach for my phone.
14. Leave the room without saying when I'll be back.
15. Say "fine" or "whatever" to end the conversation.
16. Feel my heart pound or my mind go blank, and shut down.
Scoring Part A. Add up each group of four. Each horseman gets a score from 0 to 12.
Score | What it suggests |
0 to 3 | An occasional visitor. |
4 to 7 | A regular. Worth watching. |
8 to 12 | Your go-to move when things get hard. Start here. |
Your highest score is your lead horseman. If two are tied, notice whether one tends to show up first and the other follows. For a lot of people, criticism comes first and contempt comes later, or defensiveness comes first and stonewalling comes later. That order tells you something.
Part B: Which dance do we get into?
When the two of us get stuck...
The Blame Game
We both end up pointing at each other.
Fights feel like a trial where someone has to lose.
We both get loud, sharp, or sarcastic.
Afterward, each of us is sure the other one started it.
Hide and Seek
5. One of us pushes to talk it out, and the other tries to end the conversation.
6. The more one of us follows, the more the other pulls away.
7. One of us ends up feeling alone, and the other ends up feeling like they can't win.
8. Fights end with one of us leaving the room and the other following or fuming.
Roommates
9. We mostly talk about logistics: schedules, kids, money, chores.
10. We've stopped bringing up things that bother us. It doesn't feel worth it.
11. Days go by and we feel more like coworkers than partners.
12. It's calm between us, and the calm feels lonely.
Scoring Part B. Add up each group of four, 0 to 12 each. Your highest score is the dance you fall into most. Many couples score in more than one. That's normal. Like Devon and Jules, a lot of couples move from one to the next over the years.
Bonus: in Hide and Seek, which role do I play?
If Hide and Seek was your highest or second-highest dance, answer these four using the same 0 to 3 scale.
Seeker
When there's distance between us, I'm the one who brings it up.
When my partner pulls away, I push harder.
Hider
When things heat up, I'm the one who needs space.
When my partner pushes, I go quiet or leave.
Add each pair (0 to 6). The higher score is your usual role. If they're close, you may switch roles depending on the topic. Money might make you the seeker while sex or in-laws make you the hider.
What to do with your results
1. Compare, and get curious about the gaps. Did you both pick the same dance? If not, that's great information. One of you may experience the relationship as Hide and Seek while the other experiences it as Roommates. The gap between your answers is often where the most important conversation lives.
2. Lead with your own horse. Share your Part A results first, before you say anything about your partner's. "My lead horseman is defensiveness. I'm not proud of it." That one sentence can change the whole tone. I call it bust yourself first, and it works.
3. Name the dance together, as a "we." "I think we're doing Hide and Seek again." Not "you're hiding again." The dance is the problem. Neither of you is.
4. Pick one antidote for your lead horseman. Gottman paired each horseman with an antidote. Practice one for two weeks.
Horseman | Antidote | What it sounds like |
Criticism | Gentle start-up | "I feel lonely when we don't talk at dinner. Could we put the phones away tonight?" |
Contempt | Build appreciation and respect | Catch your partner doing something right, and say it out loud. |
Defensiveness | Take responsibility, even for part | "You're right. I did say I'd handle it." |
Stonewalling | Self-soothe, then come back | "I'm flooded. I need twenty minutes. I'll come find you." |
5. Look for the fear under the dance. Use the table above. If you're the seeker, try saying the fear instead of the criticism: "I miss you." If you're the hider, try saying the fear instead of leaving: "I'm scared I'm letting you down." That's the softer thing EFT is always reaching for.
A word for Roommates couples especially. Don't wait for a fight to tell you something's wrong. If you scored highest there, the move is to reach first, small and on purpose. A hand on the back. "I miss us." It will feel awkward. Do it anyway.
When Devon and Jules took this in my office, they had both scored highest on Roommates. But their Part A results surprised them. Jules was still carrying criticism from the seeker years, just quietly, in private thoughts. Devon was still stonewalling, even though there was nothing left to hide from. Jules said, "So we didn't stop the chase. We just both got tired." Devon reached over and took Jules's hand. That was the first reach either of them had made in a long time.
A note on safety
Everything here is for two people who are safe with each other. If what you're living with is violence, threats, intimidation, or control, that is not a dance or a horseman to work on together. Please get help. The National Domestic Violence Hotline is 1-800-799-7233 (or text START to 88788). And if contempt has become the daily language between you, or old trauma floods one of you fast, please bring a therapist into it.
For counselors: map the dance, then find the horse
Pre-licensed counselors, this part is for you.
Most of us were trained in one model or the other. Gottman gives you a strong behavioral read. EFT gives you the attachment meaning underneath it. You don't have to pick. Here's how I use them together:
Name the dance first, in plain words. Clients rarely remember "demon dialogue." They remember "Hide and Seek." Use whatever names you choose consistently, and let the couple make them their own.
Track the horsemen by role. In Hide and Seek, expect different horsemen from each partner. If you only track the loud one, you'll miss the hider's stonewalling and accidentally side with the quiet partner.
Translate each horseman into its attachment meaning. Criticism becomes protest. Stonewalling becomes protection from flooding. Say it to the other partner, then check it. "Am I close?"
Take Roommates seriously. Couples in this pattern often present as calm and high functioning. Low conflict can read as low risk. It often isn't. Watch for flatness and for nobody reaching.
Use the assessment for discussion, not diagnosis. The gap between partners' answers is your best clinical material. Ask about it. "You both picked different dances. Tell me about that."
If you want help holding both models in the room at the same time, I supervise pre-licensed counselors (LPCCs) working toward the Colorado LPC, one on one and in a weekly online group. The interest form is on my supervision page.
Free printable version
I put this whole assessment, with scoring and the antidote table, into a printable handout so you can each fill it out and compare. Download it free here.
If you want to go deeper into your cycle, my free workbook, Naming Our Cycle, walks you through mapping it together. Get it here.
And if you'd like someone in the room while you talk through your results, I offer a free 20-minute consultation for couples in Golden, the Denver metro, and anywhere in Colorado by telehealth. Book a time here.
Frequently asked questions
What are the Blame Game, Hide and Seek, and Roommates? They are Dr. John O'Malley's plain-language names for Sue Johnson's three demon dialogues: Find the Bad Guy, the Protest Polka, and Freeze and Flee. Dr. O'Malley is a couples therapist in Golden, Colorado, who uses them to help couples spot their negative cycle quickly.
What are the demon dialogues? The demon dialogues are three negative patterns Sue Johnson describes in Hold Me Tight. Couples fall into them when they feel disconnected and scared. In each one, the pattern takes over and both partners end up hurt.
How do the Four Horsemen relate to the demon dialogues? The Four Horsemen are the specific behaviors that keep each pattern going. Mutual attack (the Blame Game) runs on criticism, defensiveness, and contempt. Pursue and withdraw (Hide and Seek) usually pairs one partner's criticism with the other's defensiveness and stonewalling. Mutual withdrawal (Roommates) runs on stonewalling and quiet contempt.
Which of the Four Horsemen is the most damaging? Gottman's research found contempt to be the strongest predictor of divorce. Contempt often grows out of long-unanswered criticism, so working on the criticism early helps head it off.
Is it bad that we don't fight anymore? Not necessarily. But if the quiet comes with distance, flatness, and nobody reaching for each other, it may be the Roommates pattern. That pattern deserves attention even though it looks calm.
Is this assessment a diagnosis? No. It's a clinically informed reflection tool, not a validated psychological test. Use it to start a conversation, ideally with a couples therapist if the results feel heavy.
References
Johnson, S. M. (2008). Hold me tight: Seven conversations for a lifetime of love. Little, Brown. (Conversation 1, "Recognizing the Demon Dialogues.")
Gottman, J. M. (1994). What predicts divorce? The relationship between marital processes and marital outcomes. Lawrence Erlbaum.
Gottman, J. M., & Silver, N. (1999). The seven principles for making marriage work. Crown.
The Gottman Institute. The Four Horsemen: The antidotes. gottman.com
About the author. Dr. John O'Malley, PhD, LPC, is a couples therapist and clinical supervisor at O'Malley Counseling PLLC in Golden, Colorado. He holds a PhD in Counselor Education and Supervision from the University of Wyoming, is a Clinical Professor in the Division of Counseling & Psychology at the University of Denver, and is a past Department Chair of Counseling at Regis University. He practices evidence-based approaches, including Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) with a Gottman-informed approach, with couples in Golden and by telehealth across Colorado. He also trains and supervises pre-licensed counselors working toward the Colorado LPC. More about Dr. O'Malley.